A Hidden Life .......................................... 9/10
This movie isn't a masterpiece. It's a movie piece.
First, I have to say I do camera work so this review is coming from someone who works behind the camera and can appreciate a technical aspect of film from the inside out. The things I liked outweighed the things I did not like from this movie. The music was great. The acting was great. The camera work was fantastic. The entire movie seemed like watching a ballet. To me the cinematography looks as if it is a hybrid of documentary style and hollywood studio. The editing also seems like it comes from a documentary. I think it makes the movie much more grounded and it was something that fit well with the story. I'm glad Malick, decided to use a story that was mostly written for him, since it was based on true events. The movie asks a question and it really leaves the audience to question if the main character did the right thing or not. I think if Malick continues to do more stories based on real events then it will show his best qualities when it comes to being a director and writer.
The things I did not like: It's too long. Should be 2 hours at most. I think they just like so many shots they lost track of time. I would of changed the ending. It could have been more powerful if it showed a modern day family looking back at old photos of the main characters in this story. They could of said, “My grandfather stood up and said no to the Nazies, when no one else did." I would of changed the end text to:
Ecclesiastes 12:14
For God shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether
it be good, or whether
it be evil.
Lastly, the theme of A "Hidden" Life works very well as a movie in the context of this story. Something hidden being put on a movie theater screen. The towns people thought he was crazy but people today would think he is doing the right thing. I'd like to watch it again, hopefully it's not too slow the second time.
Should of been nominated for more awards.