Being able to sing doesn't make you a musician does it?ONLY sang, man you are pretty harsh!
The girl is a REAL musician because she plays instruments. Okay dude.
I think I will take my fake-musician-singing-ass out of this thread, lol.
I actually like bradley cooper.I think you just don't like either (a) Bradley Cooper or (b) A Star is Born or (c) both.
It does. I'm in a band. I only sing. I'm referred to as a musician. Like, if I screw up "Fucking musicians" Or, "What's it like being a musician?"Being able to sing doesn't make you a musician does it?
Ah yes but she has written at least ONE song by herself right?I don't deny that this girl is talented. I mean look at her videos, I've never seen video clips like this before. and I understand that if you admire someone it's tempting to give that person all the credits it's just a mental thing. But to be honest in the world of entertainment, specially in music there is always a co-something. No one does it all solo. There is a big team of talent behind every project, they all contribute. But sadly in the world of music the singer tends to get most of the attention. Most of melanie's song's are co-written:
Yes yes but you go on tour or perform at some point right? I can buy a ticket and see you do music?It does. I'm in a band. I only sing. I'm referred to as a musician. Like, if I screw up "Fucking musicians" Or, "What's it like being a musician?"
And he is more than "able" to sing, he sang the songs of a film and put out a record! More than me right at this moment, so yes he is.
Apparently me lol.It's not really that interesting. You are trying to apply labels instead of looking at their work. Is he a book definition musician? Who cares?!
I do like him. but i'm not gonna go out to a nice restaurant he owns and pay $300 for a meal because he acted as a chef lol.We get it man. You don't like him.
they are a writer but they arent a professional writer.I hear what you are saying. But how about this... how many people come here and say they want to know how to be become a writer, all they've written is one poem and a short... and we tell them, "You are a writer!"
I never meant to create a straw man argument I really thought we were talking about professional singers the entire time.That's a straw man argument I never said he was a pro. I said he was a musician because of what he did. So know you're just putting words in people's mouths.
Most of her music videos contain short stories so she has plenty of practice directing at this point.It had an Alice In Wonderland/Ugly Betty vibe from the parts I saw, and looked interesting.