Episode 4: 5/5
Episode 5: 2/5
Episode 6: 2/5
May not be a popular opinion, but they've all been garbage IMO except for a new hope. there are so many things wrong with the other ones.
I wouldn't use the word, "garbage," but I pretty much agree with you. Once the series became the Muppet Show, with Yoda and then the ....(gasp!) teddy bear Ewoks, I was mixed. The rest of EMPIRE and JEDI were pretty cool (snow battle, asteroid field and forest speeder chase, particularly). And the music was just great, especially in EMPIRE.
But, yeah, the original, untouched STAR WARS (where Han shoots first) was amazing. But I have a thing against muppets, so even some of the characters (devil, wolfman, etc.) in the bar bothered me. Not Chewbacca, because he looks real - but the fake looking stuff didn't cut it.
As for the new trilogy. Popcorn fun, but I can't stand the overuse of CGI, where it allows Anakin to jump out of air speeders, thousands of feet up. I just can't buy it. Oh, and Jedis are forbidden to marry? Anakin's father was the Force? The force is no longer just the energy of all living things, but midichlorians in one's genes?!!!! The whole philosophy seemed to shift.
If there's a character even remotely like Jar Jar, I'm getting up and leaving the theater.
I think we are going to be happy with Abrams' version. He said that he was going for as much reality (stuff actually seen on set) as possible. This was great to hear!