Thanks to Netflix, been rewatching some old Disney films I liked as a kid.
The Sword In The Stone -
6/10
When I was young, I loved this movie, but I always thought it would have been better without the songs. Time has not changed my opinion; in fact, some of them I found very grating. Still, loved the wizard's duel and I have a soft spot for getting me into Arthurian myths. I'm probably not going to want to rewatch it anytime soon though.
Robin Hood -
8/10
This time around, the songs work a little better (and are better songs), so while I'm still not a fan of musicals, I like it more here. I may have liked this one better as a kid (can't say which one I watched more often though), and it holds up pretty well. A cartoon fox is the first thing I think about when watching any adaptation of Robin Hood...impressive since it's been about 20 years since I'd last seen it! I still love the film, which is more than I can say about Sword In The Stone, so I'm sure I'll rewatch it before two long
(and now I'm cheating because I don't think this one is on Netflix. It's the only one I own on DVD though and watched it at the same time)
The Black Cauldron -
9/10
My girlfriend (also a fantasy fan, but had never seen this) repeated several times throughout watching "how did this ever get made?" Far more grim and gruesome than most Disney...you'd have to go back to Fantasia and even that didn't have the rotting flesh stripped off the bones of the villain at the end. No songs so I can't complain about that. Loved it when it first came out, but Disney sort of buried it, so it was years before I saw it again. Easily my favorite Disney cartoon and it still is. If you haven't read the books, it sort of combines the first two of Lloyd Alexander's Prydain Chronicles (5 in the series), which uses Welsh mythology and folklore as a touchstone. Rereading the books now, after watching the cartoon, I would love to see someone do a proper version. Fantasy is pretty popular these days, so maybe now's the time to do it!
(and I'm sure Disney has all film rights locked down on that, but if any of you somehow decide to make these films, you are hereby obligated to have me do the music )