Requiem For A Dream directed by Darren Aronofsky - 8/10 or 8.5/10 or 9/10
Glad you liked it! Sounds like you're conflicted, but at least you gave it a shot and liked it somewhat.
The beginning of the film is decent stuff. It's good but not great. I don't like how Aronofsky takes out all of his film school tricks here, they don't always work. Having a distinctive cinematic style does not make a film more artistic.
Just to play devil's advocate, the techniques he used in the film were made popular and some even started by him. Throughout his filmography, he has used uncomfortable closeups, jarring split screen effects, jump cuts, snorricam shots, and bizarre sped up/slowed down shots.
The second half of the film is much better, however it is too derivative from Perfect Blue. The highlight for me is the Perfect Blue inspired (though not copied like other scenes) scene with the refrigerator. That scene was just incredible filmmaking, and I haven't been sucked in such a surreal scene since I saw Perfect Blue actually LOL.
I gotta check perfect Perfect Blue out. Was that the anime one about the singer? I forget.
The story of the film is good, but part of my problem is that it drives its themes and its characters too much without giving time to properly develop a realistic world.
Again, I'm going to play devil's advocate. That might have been Arnofsky's goal. I mean, seeing the characters are all train wrecks in slow motion, with a twisted perception of reality, and a slow disconnection from reality, isn't that a bit fitting? I mean, the characters aren't necessarily in a realistic world, they're confused and don't see reality as it is.
(although there is a little bit too much use of close-up for my tastes, though that is personal aesthetic opinion)
What are you talking about? Too close for comfort?
This leads me to my last point. The film barely explores the issue of what leads the characters to addiction, and I took issue with this. My father pointed out that the film explored it in a more subtle manner, which I agree with, but I argued back that the film does not portray a realistic enough world to get away with that subtlety. So for me, the film still falls flat on this point.
Personally, I found the film to be an interesting exploration of
why?, but depending on people's experiences, they may perceive it differently. As someone who has known drug addicts, I find the film to be very relatable. The older woman in the film is a complete mess. She feels the desire to be beautiful and flawless. She wants to be a "somebody". Her attempts to lose weight and take various medicines to try to maintain mental stability and regain her youthful appearance lead to delusions and twisted perceptions of reality lead to a dependence on this drug, and the downfall that occurs once misery from her real life enters her fantasies, or when the drug wears off.
Although that's more of a personal thing. Obviously, we both take different messages and ideas from the film. So, yeah
-----
If Requiem for a Dream was shown in D.A.R.E. programs, I can assure all teachers and instructors that no kid will ever touch drugs again
Hey kids, wanna take drugs?!
http://images.fanpop.com/images/image_uploads/Requiem-requiem-for-a-dream-556625_770_495.jpg
Students: ...
------
Watched
The Family w/ Robert De Niro - 6/10
Decent flick. It's a lacking film, but I was laughing my @ss off a couple of times, and the acting was just awesome. Not to mention the great cinematography and sound design. Although the film did have some plot holes, and began to die out in the last 30 minutes. But overall a fun watch.
Rush - 8/10
Not bad. Great story told respectfully. Some great performances, amazing scenes, fantastic cinematography, and lovely sound design. Although the pacing did feel a bit off sometimes, and the heavily stylized color grading gave the film an artificial film. Good flick.