OK. I've watched both the film and the doc.
I expect certain things from a low budget sci fi film:
1) Slightly Cheesy costumes, check - although, I must say, they weren't all that bad
2) Big Alien who we end up seeing in a slightly disappointing full shot, check - although the look at it in the Doc wasn't all that bad... the filter applied to get rid of the fur looked a bit off rather than other worldly.
3) Horrible FX make-up, sadly lacking, this stuff was actually quite good.
4) Campy acting - a little bit, but not that bad all around. The actors actually did a good job, which was a nice surprise.
5) Bad CG elements - They were here, and not... um... There were some shots that Stuck out alot, however most of that was because I watched it on a Mac and am assuming it was color corrected on a PC without the use of the scopes. The blacks were washed out on the non-cg elements, while nice and rich on the CG. The silver fighters in the sky... absolutely convincing! The crash landing ship. Well composited into a great moving plate, but again, the blacks didn't match the plate. The fire was a bit unblended as well in that shot, and perhaps a bit too saturated. This is the worst part of this movie, which makes it really acceptable as a low-budget sci fi indy film in my book.
6) Horrible story, sadly, this was really lacking - from concept to dialog, it was of unusually good quality - darn you for dashing my expectations... Even the ending was good - grrr.
7) Bad Audio, nope, almost perfect... I heard off camera noise twice and a stray echo once
The music didn't interfere with the story
9) Amateurish camera work - Mostly spot on, some frames that were slightly static, none that were bad in terms of movement.
10) Crappy Editing: good, there were no points I found myself yelling "CUT!" at the screen (I really do that).
Overall, if the color correction had been better, I'd be able to say that I've seen less professional stuff on the scifi(syfy) channel. That was really the only sticking point for me.
So in terms of meeting my expectations, this film is a complete failure except for the color correction gaffes... Which is to say, this is really an exceptional piece of work considering its budget and crew size. Well done! Exceedingly watchable! I even liked the ending, which is really unusual for me to say about an indy flick!