fernando97 -- If you found my list confounding, wait'll you get a load of this -- I've never seen "Godfather II", because "Godfather" bored me to death. I wouldn't normally try to associate myself with Peter Griffith, but he kinda sums it up, perfectly...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRsemHatx-o
Alcove -- I'm curious to hear your take on "Prometheus", if/when you see it, because after watching it, I couldn't help but think of "Contact". They're obviously very different, but I think they've got similar threads running through them.
Ray -- Jake Sully vs. any of the lead characters in your top-10 list, in a no-holds-barred battle to the death. Hands-down, my money is on Sully. The only competition would be Mr. Incredible, but I still take Jake because he rides on the back of a freaking dragon!
JoshL -- I love the idea of making a top-10 of everyone else's top-10s.
MichaelAllen -- I don't
try to cause trouble. I do. I can't help it, I'm all jacked-up on Mountain Dew.
Nick -- I'm surprised to see "Scream" on your list. Not because it isn't a great movie (it is), I'm just surprised it's on
your list. I assume you've seen "Cabin in the Woods", right?
Okay, I've compiled a list of films that have multiple votes (this took way longer than I thought it would). "Casablanca" is kicking butt, with 5 votes. If you count an entire franchise as one entity, then "Indiana Jones" is a close 2nd, with 4 votes, with the "Star Wars" and "Godfather" franchises each garnering 3 votes. But the actual current 2nd place is "Shawshank", with 3 votes.
One other thing I've noted -- there's no question which director keeps popping up more often than any others. I think there's pretty good reason why he is, and likely always will be, my favorite.