• Wondering which camera, gear, computer, or software to buy? Ask in our Gear Guide.

Which one do you prefer - darker or lighter?

Which one do you prefer? The first clip - darkest one, or the second clip - lightest one?

I know this is relative, but at first impact what's your answer?


Thank you very much

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cfv7eQvh3Es
 
Last edited:
20130320BebosLighterDarker_zps8e7949ef.png

Darker, unless it's supposed to be a just before sunrise shot.
Streetlights look silly when they're on in the daytime, although it clearly happens.
Films are typically not about reality, though.
Para-reality, but not reality.

Depends upon the nature of the film, really.
If it's thoughtful and self-naveling go with lighter.
If it's actiony pablum go with the more dramatic darker.
 
I like the fact that you can see more in the lighter image, but that's a given. It all depends on what effect you're trying for and it's context. For this single shot, lighter allows more visibility. If this is part of a film though, I guess the darker version looks more... filmic.
 
20130320BebosLighterDarker_zps8e7949ef.png

Darker, unless it's supposed to be a just before sunrise shot.
Streetlights look silly when they're on in the daytime, although it clearly happens.
Films are typically not about reality, though.
Para-reality, but not reality.

Depends upon the nature of the film, really.
If it's thoughtful and self-naveling go with lighter.
If it's actiony pablum go with the more dramatic darker.

Thanks.

I was afraid the dark scene looked too dark to be useable. I think it's fine on my screen, but most of my firends usually tell me my images/footage are too dark...
Can be a monitor thing or just preferences...
 
I'll second that it's out of context of the rest of the shots though... but if I were composing / lighting / exposing a shot as a stand alone, I prefer higher contrast within the shot to show shapes better.
 
Back
Top