+1
Yup.
Exactly WHERE or from WHOM is the money being paid to the screenwriter coming from?
A screenplay
IS NOT a "pseudo-fixed price" commodity like a pick up truck where it doesn't matter if you're a teen wanting a F-350 just to go pu$$y cruising at the local high school, a landscaper wanting the same truck to haul mowers and crew, or a LLC rancher hauling cattle to market - they're all pretty much going to be paying the same thing for the same truck.
A screen play
IS a wildly "variable value" commodity most often dependent upon the total film product's production cost.
If you're the writer/director/producer of a drama screenplay like... '
50/50' (any of us SHOULD be able to shoot something technically simple like this) how much of your crowdfunding proceeds are you actually going to take away from the production and promotion just to pay yourself for writing it? A few hundred? A few thousand? Ten thousand? A hundred thousand?
If you wrote that exact same screenplay and your local community theater wanted to produce it how much do you think they're going to pay or should pay for it? They plan on spending about $100,000 on production. A few hundred? A few thousand? Ten thousand? A hundred thousand?
What if a small independent director/producer approached you to film your screenplay? They plan on spending about $1.5million. How much do you think they're going to pay or should pay for it? A few hundred? A few thousand? Ten thousand? A hundred thousand?
What if a larger independent prodco was willing to spend >$5M?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50/50_(2011_film)
Screenplay values are tied directly to production budgets rather than any fixed commodity price.
Generally speaking, outside of any union minimums, they're valued at around 2-5% of a film's production budget, the bigger the budget the smaller the percentage.
Code:
THEATRICAL BUDGET THRESHOLDS
LOW BUDGET - Photoplay costing less than $5,000,000
HIGH BUDGET - Photoplay costing $5,000,000 or more
Also, writer's get paid for re-writes!
http://www.wga.org/uploadedFiles/writers_resources/contracts/min2011.pdf
Above '08 original:
http://www.imsdb.com/scripts/50-50.html
Shooting draft:
http://www-deadline-com.vimg.net/wp...INAL_Shooting_Draft_12-1-11__111215013022.pdf