Life is what you make it. Film schools are much the same. You can step up, work on as many projects as possible and try different areas. Or you can be an assistant editor or grip on a few projects and skate out the door with a weak education.
We need to know what you want walk out the door with? Do you want to direct? Write? Shoot? Edit? Grip? Audio?
If you have an area of interest, if would help steer you in the right direction.
If you want a general education, then film school is good. Again, it's what you make it. NYU could work for you if you just say this is what I want, help or get out of the way. A small school could work as long as they have enough gear. I've seen small community colleges with 35mm and 16mm cameras, extensive grip and lighting packages, edit stations and more gear than some film schools I've visited.
Do some research, see what's out there and then visit a 2-3 schools.
If you're serious about getting into the hollywood system, then I recommend looking at Southern California. They have connections to that system that you're not going to find elsewhere. Again, nothing is guaranteed. It is what you make it.
Regarding Full Sail, I've had students from that program grip and gaff for me and they were very good. I think it's great for people who have picked a specific area and want to focus on that. It's not cheap and is not a rip off, unless you expect them to do it all for you.
Scott