hi, i wasn't even going to comment any more until a couple of you tried to defend me a bit, so, look, thanks for the support, but honesty... it's just not worth wasting your time... I just tossed the clip up because I had i lying around and it's got a bit better audio than the original... that simple.
it was a student film I was asked by the VA to act as executive producer and mentor for the new director ( a vet) at NYFA... he started to try to pull the scene together but asked me to finish directing on set to sort out the bit of a problem scene for him... so we we went with the plan and made the fight what it is... I can't and won't ask anyone to change an opinion, but I kinda like to rough edge to the edits as they work for the overall story's emotional moment. But what do I know...
The funny thing is the film is a 20 min short that's won a bunch of awards internationally for production quality , directing and acting... and many of the judges commented on the believability and quality of the fight. ... go figure.
I just tried to offer the OP something that had, IMHO, a bit more real sound design and a bit of good acting providing a more emotional edge to a fight. I'm sorry i even bothered.
again, thanks for the support, but this guy is just too full of himself and he's always gonna try for the last word.
the guy jumped to a incorrect conclusion and isn't about to back down from it. Let it go.
cheers
geo
it was a student film I was asked by the VA to act as executive producer and mentor for the new director ( a vet) at NYFA... he started to try to pull the scene together but asked me to finish directing on set to sort out the bit of a problem scene for him... so we we went with the plan and made the fight what it is... I can't and won't ask anyone to change an opinion, but I kinda like to rough edge to the edits as they work for the overall story's emotional moment. But what do I know...
The funny thing is the film is a 20 min short that's won a bunch of awards internationally for production quality , directing and acting... and many of the judges commented on the believability and quality of the fight. ... go figure.
I just tried to offer the OP something that had, IMHO, a bit more real sound design and a bit of good acting providing a more emotional edge to a fight. I'm sorry i even bothered.
again, thanks for the support, but this guy is just too full of himself and he's always gonna try for the last word.
the guy jumped to a incorrect conclusion and isn't about to back down from it. Let it go.
cheers
geo