CF, thanks for representing your silent masses. I have had this conversation/debate with many young 'ens that feel as you do. You are not "wrong" as it is 100% opinion and subjective.
Also, god bless ya for only seeing movies in the theater. No matter what I do to trick out my home setup, it will NEVER replace seeing a movie in the theater. NEVER. My first time seeing CITIZEN KANE was on a 35mm film print in a historic theater with 900 seats downtown. I loved it. Don't know if it would have had that impact on me on DVD or VHS.
Also, god bless ya for only seeing movies in the theater. No matter what I do to trick out my home setup, it will NEVER replace seeing a movie in the theater. NEVER. My first time seeing CITIZEN KANE was on a 35mm film print in a historic theater with 900 seats downtown. I loved it. Don't know if it would have had that impact on me on DVD or VHS.