Received it, and did a quick unboxing and a couple tests.
I'm pretty sure it's less noisy than the tascam DR40, but my room sound is noisy and I have a bird which can get really loud at unexpected times. I'm certain the preamps are hotter -- using the same condenser mic, I could get a lot more volume. (Gain doesn't mean it's less noisy, of course, but I suspect it is anyway.) Set to get the same output level I had on my DR-40 at the same distance with the same mic, there's very little hiss.
But the main reason I got this was because of the issue I had on several tracks while recording a movie -- the tascam had some subtle beeping around 3000Hz. I think a notch filter will remove that, but it was definitely annoying. Guitar Center was great about taking it back and ordering the Zoom.
I don't know anyone with a DR-60D to test this H6 against. I'll ping the locals and see.
Interestingly, I noticed that there's a tiny bit more hiss on input 2-4 than 1 with no inputs. I need to test it with a muted mic.
Overall, the form factor seems good, build is solid, and the 4 inputs + options seems like a great deal. I did look at the 60D, and maybe I should've gone for that, but the (potential) 6 XLRs vs half that on the 60D (2 XLR + one ganged minijack) seemed like a pretty good thing to have, even if the optional +2 XLRs don't have phantom.
From my minimal testing so far, here's what I like:
- Many XLRs, and even though they don't lock, they attach solidly. Maybe continued use will affect this, but it feels solid.
- Good form factor. Feels like a streamlined tricorder. Loops can be added to hang it from your neck or belt, but not included.
- Solid build. Plastic, but sturdy. Feels rubberized, so it's not slippery and won't show scratches.
- Hot preamps. This gives some wiggle room depending on your mics.
- "Seems" like it has decent noise floor. I haven't tested this quantitatively yet. Feels better than the tascam DR40, and it's way better than the zoom h4n. Most charts place the DR40 and h4n noise floors the same, so it should be much better.
- Good pots. Very smooth. I can see getting confused, though... there is a gap between input pairs 1-2 and 3-4 where your fingers can turn the dials easily. As expected, clockwise is up, counter-clockwise is down. But when you're turning inputs 1-2, swiping your finger down turns them up. But on inputs 3-4, swiping your finger down, turns them down. I'm going to mess this up at a critical time.
- Line out and headphone out with volume... no pot, but shouldn't be too annoying.
- Intuitive basic controls.
- Input switches for each ... really straightforward! Mixes the inputs into the headphones. Haven't tested the L/R for the individual inputs, which would make separating them apart very easy.
- Nice color display. It will be really nice on a dark set, since I couldn't see a damn thing in the dark on the tascam except the record button.
- Optional XLR module is cheap.
- X-Y mic feels overbuilt and sturdy. Oddly large mics, too.
- Solid carrying box, although unpadded.
- Startup time isn't stupid.
Here's what I don't like:
- Display is a little bit small with all the VU meters jammed into a tiny screen. It is a little difficult to see levels clearly.
- Mid-side mic feels like a toy. It needs a wire cage. I expect this to break if abused even a little.
- While there's a big improvement, inputs still seem noisier than I want. Maybe I'm just spoiled from playing with studio gear, so I shouldn't knock the field recorders.
- The one time I forget to verify a connection, I'm going to lose an XLR since it didn't lock in.
- Attaching the optional shotgun just seems like a bad idea. This thing is sensitive, and picks up a lot of handling noise.
- Despite the handling noise mentioned above, I'd love just a single omni built-in, for emergency recording like the DR100mk2 (ignoring the fact the dr100 also has cardiods).
- Could get a little unwieldy with more than two XLRs attached.
- Occasional blast of bass when switching inputs (even when they're turned down).
Things I'm going to check on:
- Can it work as a USB mic for my computer, or is that only for transferring files?
- Does LR fading work properly for each individual input? I'm assuming yes.
- Can I easily turn on/off the display to save batteries, without having to go through a menu?
- What's the battery life using my Eneloops and phantom?
- What happens to the current recording when batteries die? How much warning is there? How accurate is the warning?
- Is the included software (Cubase 6LE) useful?
- Does the clock drift?
- Formatting options, saving options, dual-mono mode, etc.
Things I want that it doesn't have:
- I want a very small, protection cover for the front pins when using without the separate H6 mics. Easily designed - just a piece of plastic that clips into the clip spaces.
- I want a cover to guard the pots from turning -- basically a finger guard where it's easy to turn with a fingertip, but difficult to turn if it brushes up against something, or when transporting. Looks like this can be easily attached, and the existing small finger guards removed with two screws.