Nice review, I'll keep checking back to see the rest of your 10! This really is the best time of year! All time favorites, huh...well it might be easier listing the horror films I *don't* like! We'll try though. In no particular order, and likely to change at any time (I love way too many movies to come up with consistent "favorite" lists). So then, top 10 for Monday the 24th:
Hellraiser (with the exception of 3, 4 and 6, though I'll sit through 3 if I'm in the mood)
Legend of Hell House
Susperia (and Inferno...really, we could just say "the collected works of Dario Argento" and be covered)
In The Mouth of Madness
Prince of Darkness (most Carpenter I could take or leave, but those two are favorite films of mine)
Romero's Living Dead movies (emphasis on the first and Diary)
Exorcist series (3 is actually my favorite, but the original is a classic and Dominion is pretty good)
Poltergeist (too bad the loss of Julian Beck kept the third from being the scariest movie ever!)
Nosferatu (both versions, and I loved Shadow of the Vampire too!)
The Others (really NAILS the classic ghost story/haunted house film)
As you can tell, I definitely lean towards supernatural horror, but I like everything. From sci-fi horror (Alien, of course) to horror comedy (Shaun of the Dead, Dead Alive, Evil Dead, etc), so bad it's funny horror (Troll 2, Leprechaun in Space, any Wishmaster movie after the first, where they were at least SORTA trying). I appreciate the occasional action horror (Resident Evil, House on Haunted Hill remake, etc) or classic horror (ANYTHING with Vincent Price or Christopher Lee). I also have a soft spot for killer scarecrow movies...couldn't tell you why!