I'll cop to having a perverse interest in dissecting "failures", especially those which "seem" to have all the elements required, yet somehow... fail.
My current fave is "WHY does
BABYLON AD suck sooooo bad?"
- It has a very well known lead in a classic/typical role for him.
- The film has a $70M budget.
- Sci-Fi, especially near-future dystopin world, is ragingly popular.
- Gots plenty of action.
- Wonderful scope and changes of scenery adventure.
- Guns & fighting
- Dialog is no worse than usual, par.
- Plot and story are par
- Cinematography is fine.
- blah, blah, blah
And still... meh.
Completely, understand your point.
Looked good in your mind.
Reads good on paper.
Scene looks fine in camera.
Blocking is fine.
Acting is spot on.
Lines (likely) delivered with constructive corrections.
Editing 1-2-3 fine.
And still... meh.
GRRRRRR!!!!!
What's missing in the secret sauce?