I think that's false, Boz and here's why.
You are legally able to create back-up coppies of your media correct? You have CD Roms and make a backup you can as long as you don't share that copy with anyone. There are programs available for it and even entire websites which tell you how to get around the copy protection (gamecopyworld).
For music, you are legally able to make backup coppied, make them into MP3's, copy the entire disc, etc... It's legal as long as it's for the purchaser's own use, can't share it.
Now we come to movies, in the VHS days there were VCR's that you could buy that would allow you to make backup coppies of your tapes. These were sold at nationally recognized stores. You could make a backup copy if you didn't share it.
Now, in these days you can record TV programs to harddrive or DVD instantly. That's copying right?
I personally feel that if you need to make a backup copy of a DVD you are legally allowed as long as it remains yours. I feel that if you copy your own DVD of your own footage that you shot and own all rights to and give it away, that it's legal.
How do you copy a CD ROM? with software or hardware. How do you copy a music CD? with software or hardware. How do you copy DVDs? with hardware or software.
The tool is not illegal. If you use that tool to copy a copyrighted DVD and then you give it away and/or sell it, you're in violation of the law. If you use that tool to copy a personally created DVD where you own all the rights, then you're not in violation of the law.
So here's scenario. I make a DVD for one of the shorts I made. I own all the rights to the footage, actor clearences adn all that. Then I put it up for sale, say $7 including shipping. I get 1000 orders (WOOHOO!!!). In the mean time my PC crashes hard and all data is lost. I re-install all my apps but the movie data is gone, all I have is that master DVD.
You are saying that it's illegal for me to make a copy of it? I think not.
I use a ripper to keep a copy on my hard drive and burn coppies with my PC.
OR
I get a stand alone burner and it coppied the DVD onto its harddrive then burns the coppies.
OR
I get a standalone burner that has one reader drive and 7 burning drives. It reads my DVD and makes a copy of it onto the other 7 DVDs at the same time.
Then I package the DVD's and ship them to the customers.
How are any of these scenarios illegal?
- CootDog
Fly High
Live Large
Dream BIG!