• Wondering which camera, gear, computer, or software to buy? Ask in our Gear Guide.

Feedback Request - "Icarus`Wings" [Film Noir/Drama]

Feedback Request - "Icarus`Wings" [Film Noir/Drama] (now with in-post preview)

Good day everyone.

I`m new here, having just hatched from the registration-form :). My name is Ulrich Büch, I`m just a movie-enthusiast trying my best at screenwriting. The following is basically my second finished shortfilm script, so excuse me if some formating errors might have slipped in. Also note english is not my motherlanguage, so there might be an orthographic error either or two.

Enough of the boring stuff, let`s get to the meat of it:
I`m kindly asking for your feedback on my script for a short called "Icarus`Wings".
As the thread-title suggests, it`s at bottom a drama or film noir, I guess.

Log Line: said:
"Icarus`Wings" tells the story of businessman Matt, who, after meeting the wheelchair-bound, suicidal Virgil during an elevator ride, suddenly gets pulled into Virgils twisted suicide-plan and finds himself having to trade a life for a life...

Note this is not meant to be a children`s movie. The script contains (little) strong language, violence, use of alcohol and cigarrettes.
If you`re into Riverdancing rather than Martin Scorsese, you might dislike it and are invited to look somewhere else.

The mis-en-scéne is somewhat leaned towards animation rather than life action. This means here, I actually often tried to get away with as little shots involving complex facial animation and lip sync as I could. Thus the script may read somewhat uncommon.

So one last thing: Here are some questions I`ve been asking myself and would particularly like to hear your views of:
  • Do you think changing my characters (maybe just one of them) from male to female would add anything to the story (though I don`t think so, especially as to me this would only make sense if I changed the sex of both)?
  • On the bottom of page 18, scene 02, shot 68: Do you think this (whole) shot even adds anything worthwile to the story?
  • Do you see a way of shortening the story without considerable sacrifice?
Of course I`m also open to any other suggestions, critiques, opinions, ideas and eager to hear them!


Enough talk, here it is (PDF |25 pages): Icarus`Wings (Now on GoogleDrive.:))
As a convenient preview for you guys, here`s the first 4 pages crammed into the post :). Thx for reading.
Code:
                                                              FADE IN:
                                                                           
   1      INT. HOTEL LOBBY - NIGHT                                         
                                                                           
          1|EXTREME CLOSE UP: BUTTON                                       
                                                                           
          next to an elevator‘s doors, as A MAN‘S HAND presses it.         
          MATT wears a night blue pin striped suit, white collared         
          shirt, elegant cuff links.                                       
                                                                           
          The edge of the button glows in a bright red-orange hue,         
          like the color of blood orange pulp, to indicate the             
          elevator is about to arrive.                                     
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          2|CLOSE UP: MATT‘S RIGHT HAND                                    
                                                                           
          as HE drumms HIS fingers onto the glass panel around the         
          button while HE waits. On HIS RING FINGER, MATT wears a          
          golden wedding ring.                                             
                                                                           
          Moments later, the typical little bell sound indicates the       
          elevator cabin has arrived.                                      
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          3|OVER THE SHOULDER: MATT                                        
                                                                           
          the hair of whom is short, accurateley cut and all black. As     
          is revealed to THE CAMERA by the large mirror at the rear        
          wall of the elevator cabin, MATT wears a silver-grey tie and     
          glasses.                                                         
                                                                           
          The other two walls of the elevator cabin, as well as its        
          door, are all glass. So are the outer door in the lobby and      
          the whole elevator shaft.                                        
                                                                           
          The doors open in font of MATT, who enters the cabin. HE         
          turns to the control panel on the right wall, next to the        
          door.                                                            
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          4|TWO-SHOT: MATT‘S & ANOTHER MAN‘S RIGHT HANDS                   
                                                                           
          as MATT presses the lowermost button on the elevator‘s           
          control panel, while THE OTHER MAN uses a plant pot as an        
          ashtray, to stub out HIS cigarette.                              
                                                                           
                                                           (CONTINUED)     

          CONTINUED:                                              2.       
                                                                           
                                                                           
                              THE MAN:                                     
                    Would you please wait for me? Sir??                    
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
   2      INT. ELEVATOR CABIN - NIGHT                                      
                                                                           
          MATT hestiates as HE hears THE MAN. HE leans back a little,      
          trying to see past the heavy concrete coloumn next to the        
          outer elevator door which prevents HIM from seeing the man       
          who talked.                                                      
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          6|CLOSE UP: ELEVATOR CONTROL PANEL                               
                                                                           
          as MATT keeps the door button pressed, to prevent the doors      
          from closing before THE MAN has arrived.                         
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          7|OVER THE SHOULDER: MATT                                        
                                                                           
          looks for the man who aksed HIM to wait. Before THE MAN          
          comes into view as HE rushes to the elevator, a blindman‘s       
          stick does, reaching for the elevator‘s door.                    
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          8|MEDIUM CLOSE UP: OPEN ELEVATOR DOOR                            
                                                                           
          It now gets apparent THE MAN is in a wheelchair. HE‘S            
          obviously paraphlegic.                                           
                                                                           
          VIRGIL wears a well fitting light grey suit, white collared      
          shirt, black tie, a simple tieclip and black sunglasses.         
                                                                           
          HIS hair is wild and grey at the tips, HIS designer stubble      
          accurateley cut.                                                 
                                                                           
          MATT hurries to step aside and make way.                         
                                                                           
                              MATT:                                        
                    Uh... excuse me!                                       
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          9|EXTREME CLOSE UP: VIRGIL                                       
                                                                           
          takes off HIS sunglasses, looking up to MATT who‘d be            
          shorter than VIRGIL HIMSELF, if the latter was standing          
          rather than sitting.                                             
                                                                           
                                                           (CONTINUED)     

          CONTINUED:                                              3.       
                                                                           
                              VIRGIL:                                      
                         (smiles sarcastically)                            
                    Now before you overflow in                             
                    hypocrisy, I‘m not actually really                     
                    blind. I just use this thing at                        
                    times to pretend, for the fun of                       
                    it.                                                    
                                                                           
                              MATT:                                        
                         (confused)                                        
                    ...the fun of it...                                    
                                                                           
          VIRGIL rolls into the cabin and turns towards the control        
          panel.                                                           
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          10|OVER THE SHOULDER: VIRGIL                                     
                                                                           
          presses the topmost button, numbered 6. It‘s edge glows in       
          the blood orange hue as does the lowermost button MATT had       
          pressed before.                                                  
                                                                           
                              VIRGIL:                                      
                    Oh... the basement garage. Not my                      
                    destination... quite yet.                              
                         (after a short pause)                             
                    You know, I pretend to be blind                        
                    sometimes, it‘s funny to study                         
                    people‘s reactions when they think                     
                    I‘m paralyzed and blind.                               
                         (laughs)                                          
                    At times I add deafness into the                       
                    mix.                                                   
                                                                           
          VIRGIL looks up to MATT who stands to HIS left near the          
          mirror at the rear wall, to see HIS reaction.                    
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          11|CLOSE UP: PACK OF CIGARETTES                                  
                                                                           
          as VIRGIL fiddles one out.                                       
                                                                           
                              VIRGIL:                                      
                    I know, I know. You shouldn‘t make                     
                    fun of disabled people. But I‘m                        
                    crippled myself so I‘m free to make                    
                    fun of them as I please! Self-irony                    
                    is no crime, is it!?                                   
                         (offers the cigarettes to                         
                         MATT)                                             
                    No? ...wait a moment.                                  
                                                                           
                                                           (CONTINUED)     

          CONTINUED:                                              4.       
                                                                           
                                                                           
          VIRGIL puts away HIS pack of cigarettes and produces a white     
          marker instead.                                                  
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          12|EXTREME CLOSE UP: CIGARETTE                                   
                                                                           
          between VIRGIL‘S LIPS as HE lights it.                           
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          13|EXTREME CLOSE UP: VIRGIL‘S MARKER                             
                                                                           
          as HE pulls off the cap.                                         
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          14|CLOSE UP: THE GLASS PANE                                      
                                                                           
          making up for the right wall of the elevator-cabin,              
          inbetween the door and the control panel. VIRGIL starts to       
          write onto it as if it was a whiteboard:                         
                                                                           
          THANK YOU FOR NOT SMOKING.                                       
                                                                           
          In the foreground, swirls of blue haze indicate HE‘S not         
          adhereing to HIS own proscription.                               
                                                                           
                              VIRGIL(V.O.S.):                              
                    As we‘re just arriving in the                          
                    basement garage, may I ask you a                       
                    favour before you leave? Would you                     
                    mind getting to your car a minute                      
                    late and join me in riding to the                      
                    topmost floor? Two-three minutes,                      
                    that‘s all I‘m asking. One ride to                     
                    floor 6, and you can go to your                        
                    party.                                                 
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          15|CLOSE UP: MATT‘S FOLDED ARMS                                  
                                                                           
          HE leans against the mirror behind HIM.                          
                                                                           
                              VIRGIL(V.O.S.):                              
                         (sarcastically)                                   
                    Off course you can also choose to                      
                    violently push a helpless blind                        
                    cripple out the door.                                  
                                                                           
                                                                  CUT:     
                                                                           
          16|EXTREME CLOSE UP: VIRGIL‘S LEFT HAND                          
                                                                           
                                                           (CONTINUED)
I`m planning to eventually produce this as an animated short, though technically it might just as well qualify for life action. Animation is just sort of the corner where I come from anyway.

greetings, Kologe
 
Last edited:
  • Do you think changing my characters (maybe just one of them) from male to female would add anything to the story (though I don`t think so, especially as to me this would only make sense if I changed the sex of both)?
Of course I`m also open to any other suggestions, critiques, opinions, ideas and eager to hear them!

Hi Ulrich,

although I wasn´t able to read your whole script, I really liked the first pages of it, the whole atmosphere has something disasterous and fatal, and manages to keep up the tension because of its minimalism and concentration on visual symbolism.

I don´t think a female lead would fit into the story, because women always behave more cooperatively and helpful when it comes to these things, whereas when you use a male lead the script keeps Matt behaving in contradiction to his self preservation drive, which in my opinion fits much more into the general mood of the screenplay (although I haven´t read the whole script).

If you plan to change the gender of the wheelchairman, it would give the whole story the touch of a love story - the first thing that would come into Matts mind would be to become the knight in shining armor for a poor, mistreated woman.

Yours
Olaf

---

The world is dreaming,
a constant maze,
the dreamed-off world
takes never place.
 
Hey Olaf,

thx for your reply and kind words! To finally make my .pdf actually viewable for anyone interested, I`ve now put it on GoogleDrive.

Here`s the link (PDF |25 pages): Icarus`Wings (same in first post)

With this out of the way, I think you´re right about the "male or female"-question, Olaf. The point you made was something I`ve been thinking either.
Furthermore (though this only gets evident when one can actually read the whole thing), it`s probably save to assume the wheelchair-person (Virgil),- consciously or not - makes a deliberate descision to have exactly Matt to be his/her "victim"/involuntary helper. Like Virgil probably doesn`t just join the next best guy to use the elevator.
Thus if Virgil was actually a woman, she`d obviously be well aware of the whole sexual dimension of it all if she were to join exactly Matt in that elevator.
Thus she quite sure wouldn`t. She`d rather wait for a female (using the elevator) instead.

That`s why I felt like if changing the sex of any of my characters at all, I`d have to change that of both, for it to make any sense whatsoever, to begin with.

Anyway, I guess you`re probably right to suggest not to change this aspect alltogether.

greetings, Kologe
 
Well, I´m really looking forward to read the whole screenplay and I surely will shortly review it as soon as I find the time, but since were both Germans a totally different idea now strikes my mind.

Isn´t it kind of weird to be forced to write english language screenplays and then to discuss them in an American forum? Because there aren´t any German screenplay forums?

I now nearly feel obliged to create a German forum for all independant screenwriters and moviemakers. I surely will set all levers in motion and do everything I can to enforce this project - if it can´t be realised because of technical or organisational reasons I would have at least a clean conscience to have undertaken everything that was in my power.

I would start off with a website and a facebook group, since I´ve already programmed half a dozen of them, than I will try to hire some admins of already existing forums and give them themed sections, texts, a list of procedures concerning new members, posts and so forth.

Wouldn´t that be a real enrichment of the creative German landscape, Kollege? ...ups, Kologe?

Do you feel like linking to it?

As for the forum´s name, how about e.g.: 35mm, Close-Up or ...and action! ? Make some propositions, since as for now it´s an unwritten piece of paper...

Other than that, it would really be a pity still to be forced to invest even more time and energy into the whereabouts of a foreign country...
 
Back
Top