Casting the Lead

I recently had to "fire" the lead actor of a professional gamer web series I've been working on. It was a very hard decision because, while he certainly fit the character and was a joy to have on-set, the distance he would be travelling and his schedule just wasn't feasible.

I began the process to try and re-cast the lead role and I only had one actor submit. Physically, he kinda comes close to what I envisioned for the character, but he doesn't seem like he'd be a good fit. I asked him some off-hand questions about video games and gaming, to which he acted like he couldn't care less. I'm not saying background knowledge or experience was a prerequisite, but it would've helped. I'm not sure what his comedic chops are like. When he came in to audition and read, I saw flashes of the character, but not enough. I followed up with him after a week to ask him if he would be willing to shave for the duration of filming (he said yes). But still, I'm not entirely sold on him.

Should I have him watch the first episode to get a sense of what the role is about? The goal, of course, wouldn't be to imitate the previous actor. I just want him to see what the character is about and get a sense of what we're asking him to do. I'm kind of at a loss as to what else to do because, even before we cast the first actor last summer, no one came to read for the role. I'm not sure if it's because we're unable to pay anyone or because the concept is too "out there." It's a mockumentary about a college grad who wants to play video games professionally. My target is obviously the Internet and people who play video games.

I just don't know anymore.
 
I'm kind of surprised that you didn't get more interest in this role. It seems like the sort of thing you'd have a lot of response for. I know it's a non-paying role, but did you try local college drama departments? Or even non-actors; find yourself a gamer.

It doesn't seem necessary that the actor is into gaming, as long as the writers are. When the character would need to make a reference/in-joke, you can write that in. Thanks to youtube being filled with game clips, you can give him specific references, if he needs it. Or sit him down with an NES and Zelda and let him figure it out ;-)

I'd say try to find someone who fits the character you want. If you can't, or you want to give this guy a chance, try to identify what he's not doing, or doing incorrectly, and let him know. If the guy is good, a little direction and you can get what you want out of him!
 
Physically, he kinda comes close to what I envisioned for the character, but he doesn't seem like he'd be a good fit.

Go with your gut. If he doesn't seem right, keep looking.

My advice is to think less of what you envisioned for the character
and think more about someone who gets what you're doing - and
lives closer. I can tell you a dozen stories of casting actors who didn't
fit my first vision who turned out to be so much better than what I
envisioned. Keep looking.
 
Ya, keep looking for sure. You don't want to force this guy into a mold.

It's tough that it's an unpaid position. If you're asking someone to come in and shoot an entire webseries...driving without compensation...that gets tough. You're certainly narrowing your options there.

I'm an actor, I'm a huge gamer, I live in North Hollywood. If you were close to me I'd consider coming in to audition. You can see my reel here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WmCr6sFqX1E

I typically wouldn't do it for free, but since I'm a huge gamer I'd consider it (after seeing the pilot or a few past shows).

Thanks. Good luck.
 
Thanks for the input. Definitely wouldn't have any issues if I lived in Hollywood, lol. I've tried looking into the university theater groups in the area (University of North Carolina and North Carolina State), but like I said before, I think the concept is what's turning people off (at least in my neck of the woods). The mockumentary aspect is in the style of The Office/Parks and Recreation.

The other option I've been toying with the past couple of weeks is to focus on the female lead, also a gamer, and her team. It's going to take a weekend to figure out how to rework the story; we're supposed to start filming this month.

It's either that or take the pilot we already shot and start begging for funding.
 
Turning off potential actors? Or turning off potential viewers?

I think it's turning off potential actors. We already have a great cast in place (although, I've already lost two actors based on scheduling; not too sore about that). I'd like to think that this project doesn't fall within the mainstream in the central North Carolina film community. The pilot had overall positive feedback. It was also shown at a gaming event in the United Kingdom. So I know there's a market for it.

Now it's just a matter of finding the lead.
 
Back
Top