In another thread here on IndieTalk, I talked about structure and through that structure, you can figure out what works and what doesn't. Structure, whether it's 3 act, 5 act, 7 act or 9 act doesn't have to be formulaic. True, read a lot of screenwriting books and they will definitely talk about specific plot points you need to hit and when to hit them...
Clive is right about basics of storytelling. If you've ever read Joseph Campbell, you begin to understand that storytelling, in and of itself, carries with it, specific types of information. This information is fairly consistent throughout the world with storytellers and has been so throughout time.
We are more or less (I'm talking about the majority of the general public) hardwired to respond to certain kinds of storytelling. One example that helps support this theory is listening to music.
Take just about any song that sounds good to you personally. The notes are written to be played in a specific order. If we then talke all those notes and rearrange them in a totally different order... An order where the notes in no way fit next to one another, we end up not liking the music. In other words, we are and probably have always been hardwired to sense a certain order of things. Things could be a things to do list where we prioritize them in a certain way, or things could be a simple melody that sounds pleasing to the ear. Keep messing with the order and you can end up with chaos.
Don't worry though... I'm always up for a little chaos... LOL.
So it goes with storytelling and why we normally start with a beginning leading to the middle, and finishing at the end of a story. I'm not talking screenwriting right now. I'm talking storytelling. A thousand years ago, it would have been difficult for someone to tell a story in a different order. As we progress as human beings, so do our minds. This progression allows us a little room to start changing the order of the story BUT don't we still make sure that we tell all the best parts of the story? We do if we want our audience to enjoy it.
If I tell you a story about how I got up in the morning, brushed my teeth, took a shower, dried off, got dressed, ate breakfast, brushed my teeth again, drove to work, worked eight hours, drove back home, ate dinner, watched television, went to bed, do I really have much of a story?
Not yet...
But if I throw in some conflict, the story gets better...
I woke up this morning listening to a phone call my wife was having. In less than a minute, I realized she is having an affair with this person she's talking to.
I tried not to show any emotion, but I couldn't brush my teeth because I was crying so hard.
While in the shower, I completely broke down!
As I dried my body off, all I could see were images of my wife and this person... together.
It took me forever to get dressed.
My wife had breakfast ready for me but I just couldn't eat.
I drove to work and got there really late but I didn't care.
I didn't get any work done... Instead, I just sat there imagining my wife with this person doing all kinds of things she should be doing with me instead.
On the way home, I picked up a six pack of my favorite beer. I never drink and drive but I decided to give it a try.
She wasn't home when I got home. She left a note saying she would be very late. I need more beer.
I tried to watch TV but everything kept reminding me of my wife and the guy she's screwing around with.
I cried myself to sleep.
--See the difference?
Have you ever stood with someone who was telling you a story and it was oh so very boring? Why? Probably because nothing happened!
Conflict. Large and small. Conflict makes a story compelling. I can't tell you how many indie shorts I've seen that are very similar to what I outlined above... The boring part. If I have to watch another character that has not yet been introduced to me get out of bed, put on his clothes, brush his teeth, etc. I swear I'm gonna upchuck... LOL.
At least if someone is going to do that to us, then I want to see some conflict. Maybe the shirt has a funny smell... Maybe it shrunk... Maybe it falls apart when he puts it on... Give me something!
But back to structure...
I think you can create a plan of what you want to hit upon in your story. You can even follow all the basic structure of any Hollywood film... Just not the formula. Let me see your character do what he's supposed to do but just let me see it in a new and exciting way that I've never seen before! And if you really want to suck me in, let me see that something different RIGHT WHEN I'M EXPECTING the usual crap I always see! That's when you will get my attention. That's when I'm going to sit up in my theater seat. That's when I'm going to lean forward and pay more attention...
Rant over... LOL.
filmy