I'm a comic book fan (own a few hundred), love the movies (the good ones), love the games (the good ones), and I always look forward to comic media.
I think there are a ton of stinkers out there, but there are juuuuust enough very solid ones where I'm entertained. I've gotten chills from a few of them I can tell you.
I think your doc is solid. I think it can be big-time expanded though. It's too short. I want a full length deeper breakdown. I want more of each year...in more detail. I know that's asking you to do a lot more work, but it's far too short.
I also wasn't a fan of the half-tone effect you were using. I get your idea, and I like it, but the way it was executed was uninspired. The dots too big? Maybe a color-grade on the image to resemble a comic more? I don't know, but it could have been better. Good idea though.
Also...I didn't see a single shot of Silver Surver. Putting him--I think--into a high quality blockbuster was way overdo, and I think they nailed him. He's my favorite hero by far, and I was stoked when they used him. He needs his own full-length Origins story at the same quality of F4. Add a clip of SS in your doc, and it will go from a C+ to a B.
I really enjoyed that, nice work.
ps. And as Graeme said, I would like to see the 'fan films' and indie-level renditions (ie.
Wayne,
Dead End,
Mercury Men, etc) have a segment...